The Illicit List: Crime and Craigslist

By Kristal Hawkins

More Coming Out

When Markoff was arrested on his way to Foxwoods Casino with Megan McAllister, he was carrying $1,000 in cash. He'd also gone to Foxwoods two days after Julissa Brisman's death, winning $5300 that night. McAllister has given no public sign of having worried about her fiancé's gambling, but investigators and the media are wondering whether gambling debt may have been the motive behind the alleged robberies.

Erotic Services ad from craigslist.com

McAllister initially stood by her man, taking it upon herself to defend him to the media. She's appeared on Good Morning America to insist that he's innocent.

When Markoff and McAllister met as undergrads at SUNY, she was two years ahead of him. He proposed to her on a beach in Maine. They were to marry August 14, 2009, on the beach at McLoone's Pier House in Long Branch, N.J. McAllister's parents live in Little Silver, an upscale community on the Jersey Shore.

Diverted from Foxwoods to headquarters, McAllister panicked at the station. Her mother had warned her about the Craigslist killer, but she hadn't thought she might be engaged with him. She used a police computer to book a flight to her parents' in New Jersey. Cops drove her to the airport.

The couple had registered at Pottery Barn, Macy's and Williams-Sonoma. McAllister had bought a Vera Wang wedding dress. Sarah Maddalena and other bridesmaids had yet to meet Markoff, but McAllister's brothers attest that he seemed like an upstanding guy.

The wedding band reported that the wedding was canceled after Markoff's arrest. May 1, McAllister met with Markoff in jail to officially break their engagement.

It's not the first time in recent memory that a B.U. medical student has gained notoriety for a crime. In 2001 in Jamaica Plain, fourth-year student Daniel Mason murdered one man, wounded another, and killed their dog. The 35-year-old Worcester native had nearly removed Gene Yazgur's ear in a parking dispute; a court awarded Yazgur $118,000 in damages. Mason, once a sniper in the Israeli army, shot Yazgur—and his University of Massachusetts student roommate and their dog—rather than pay. Yazgur died. Mason was convicted and is serving a life sentence.