Lost

When Ana Lucia (Michelle Rodriguez) and Libby (Cynthia Watros) were abruptly killed during the second season of Lost, fans were shocked. But Us Weekly had already reported that producers had wanted to kill the characters off as soon as both women were arrested for driving while intoxicated in Hawaii just 15 minutes apart. (Both plead guilty and paid small fines.) Coincidence? Or maybe it was all the island's plan.